The Promise

“The Many Loving Hands of Canada’s Maple Leaf Flag”

The Honourable John R. Matheson wanted each and every Canadian to know the names of all the people who contributed in some way to bring a National Flag of Canada to fruition. The following is an in depth informative review of the individuals, agencies, Government of Canada departments and Parliamentary procedures which began in 1895/96 and concluded in 1964-65 in a final creation and design known as “The Canadian Maple Leaf Flag”

In today’s world of fast pace change and online (non-committal) communication, I am totally convinced the majority of people on earth today have forgotten the intention of making a promise (giving your word).

I have spent the past 6 ½ years working every single day to fulfill a promise I made to a friend. It was, what I thought, a fairly straight forward and simple task which I now understand was a life changing commitment.

I made this promise to a person whom I respected and admired my entire life, I knew he would not ask me to make such a promise if it would be impossible to keep.

So here I am 6 ½ years later, having spent more than 15,000 hours reviewing over 40,000 documents and talking with several hundred Canadians in very important positions to ensure my promise is never compromised .

The promise I made to my friend the Honourable John Ross Matheson was to bring awareness to all Canadians the true facts and detailed credit of exactly who and how our beloved Canadian Maple Leaf Flag was brought to fruition in 1964-65. John asked me, Bob Harper, an average blue collar worker with no political or social prowess to undertake the process which would acknowledge the many loving hands who worked for nearly 100 years to bring a truly unifying National Flag of Canada into being.

In the 52 years since the birth of the most recognized symbol of Canada in the world there have been myths and overlooked contributions from individuals and credits exaggerated by others. These myths and stories have dominated the assumed historical account of who and how the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag was created.

John Ross Matheson admitted he had made some errors in judgement in providing certain credits and was saddened to have realized the details of the work done by so many dedicated Canadians had been overlooked and not honoured in the proper way in our annals of history.

Mr. Matheson had made 2 attempts to rectify this injustice by bringing forward detailed credits in an October 1968 keynote speech at the Heraldry Society of Canada’s Annual meeting and again in 1991 in an acceptance speech at RMC. In both of these cases his plea to set the record straight was not heeded.

Mr. Matheson accomplished so much in his life and had given Canada so much, he believed in the phrase “your word is your bond” and this meant keeping your promises.

In July 1961, John Ross Matheson made a promise to Lester B. Pearson to begin researching what it would take to bring a National Flag of Canada to fruition. This promise was a commitment to a man who had made a promise to himself (Pearson) to do whatever it would take to bring an unmistakable symbol of Canada into being.

Well by now I am sure you have gathered enough of the preamble to understand making a promise can become a life changing commitment.

Now here is when things get very interesting. How does an average everyday person go about fulfilling a promise in which the information available to the Canadian public is nearly 100 years old or has been documented incorrectly? Believe me when I say I now understand what I committed to when I made my promise to Mr. Matheson, and to be totally honest I would not change any part of it.

What I have realized over the past 6 ½ years is you do not have to be a PHD or a Rhodes Scholar to bring the truth to the forefront. What you really need is persistence, tenacity, and the help of a lot of people. Asking for help has never been my greatest attribute, but it is now!!!

I have been able to fulfill this promise with the help and support of my wife Sue our adopted “Auntie Anne” and some very generous friends. I have also been provided with support from our community, MP, MPP and no less than 7 Government of Canada Departments and agencies.

I have had conversations with some of the highest ranking Government of Canada officials and department heads as well as leaders in the areas of Heraldry, History, Heritage and Education and highly regarded journalists. My unorthodox methods of reaching out to some of these truly exceptional Canadians was sometimes funny and I know I probably did not provide the level of respect their positions were used to getting, but, I got it done.

In one such detailed communication a very highly respected authority referred to me as a “Bull in a China Shop” and that is how I came across with my line of questions I am sure.

The intent of this paper is to bring awareness to what you can accomplish as an individual if you are willing to do whatever it takes to fulfill your promise. I know I have matured and probably did not take my commitments as seriously when I was young but I hope this story will bring a new sense of self values to the reader.

It has been said that as a human being there will be many people who come in and out of your life, what I have discovered is although many people use the word “friend” what they really mean is “associate” or “acquaintance”. Friend is a word which should mean something very special where as an associate or acquaintance are every day interpersonal contacts. These terms are used in everyday communication with family, fellow workers, sports groups and neighbourhoods around the entire world, so I will now ask you the reader “how many true friends” do you have?

 

I would really like to have everyone who reads this paper reflect on that question and ask themselves what you would do to keep a promise made to a friend.

Over the past 6 ½ years I have grown as a person and achieved things I could have never even thought of 10 years ago. I formed a committee to celebrate the 50th Anniversary of the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag and completed 6 community based projects all relating to the National Flag of Canada.

I truly believe all 6 projects have brought awareness to the history of who and how our most recognized symbol of Canada was brought to fruition and also how it is viewed around the entire world. I have successfully worked with Municipal, Provincial and Federal Governments, Members of Parliament, Members of the Ontario Legislature, The History Museum of Canada, Heritage Canada, the Heraldry Authority of Canada, Several Universities, Ontario Ministry of Education as well as numerous other Government of Canada departments and agencies to bring the true detailed facts to the forefront.

I have successfully collaborated with the Canadian Encyclopedia (Historica Minute) group and been recognized by the Nation Research Council of Canada for our work to bring awareness to each and every individual or organization’s effort to bring the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag to fruition. I have also written 2 books on the subject.

All of this work has been done with one single mission in mind to keep my promise.

Although I have endured some very mean spirited individuals, the over-all positive response to all of this work and detailed research has been truly gratifying and overwhelming to say the least. There will always be Nay Sayers in any large effort, but, I can say with the utmost conviction the truth will always prevail. Also if you can remember the divisive time of the Great Flag Debate in 1964 Canadians have come a very long way on a promise.

 

I would like to bring forth the result of exactly what my promise to the Honourable John Ross Matheson has produced as a document, with in this story a chronological and detailed account of who and how our beloved Canadian Maple Leaf Flag was brought to fruition in 1964/65.

More than 52 years after the Birth of the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag the following chronological, factual account has been compiled and verified by exhaustive research of archival documents, journals, magazine articles, newspaper reports and interviews with some of the last surviving participants responsible for bringing the “NOW” most recognized symbol of Canada in the World to fruition in 1964/65.  This research was conducted by  myself Robert J. Harper and a team of dedicated professionals over the past 6 ½ years to ensure the request of the “Father of Our Flag” John Ross Matheson was honoured.  Mr. Matheson wrote in an acceptance speech in 1991 his desire that the many loving hands who had worked for nearly 100 years to bring a unifying National Flag of Canada to fruition be recognized and honoured.  The following provides this recognition.

  • 1895-96 Edward M. Chadwick – Lawyer- Heraldry/History enthusiast who first recommended to the Canadian Government in 1895/96 a National Flag for Canada with the Maple Leaf being the favoured emblem.  REF, U of T library
  • February 4th 1919 Major – General (later Sir) Eugene Fiset – First person to suggest in writing February 4th 1919, the emblem of Canada be “a single red maple leaf on a white field” with 2 red borders. (Armorial Bearings). REF, Matheson files, LAC, RHSC archives October 1968 Matheson Speech
  • 1921 King George V – Proclaimed Canada’s official colours as Red & White. REF, LAC
  • 1925 Prime Minister McKenzie-King – Requested submissions for a National flag but failed to proceed with the contentious issue. REF, LAC
  • 1946 Paul Martin Sr. – Headed a committee which set the standards of a National Flag of Canada, this committee brought forth a proposal but was not pursued by Parliament. REF, LAC
  • 1948-64 George Beley – Friend and advisor to John Ross Matheson on all things relating to heraldry, flags and honours from 1948 through 1975 in Brockville Ontario. Beley was one of the founding pioneers of the Heraldry Society of Canada.  REF, RHSC, JRM memoirs
  • 1956-65 Lester B. Pearson – Prime Minister and Nobel Peace Prize winner who dedicated his efforts to bring a National Flag to Canada through the Parliamentary process in the 1960’s. REF, LAC
  • 1960-61 Members of the Liberal Party of Canada who were responsible for drafting the wording of the National Flag of Canada policy. REF LPC archives
  • 1961-65 John Ross Matheson – Member of Parliament/ Flag Expert who was responsible for bringing all of the suggestions, designs and details of the National Flag of Canada to fruition from 1961-65. REF, LAC, Flag Committee Archives
  • 1963-64 George Bist – Advertising executive who spent many hours communicating his input to Government of Canada personnel relating to the need and design of a National Flag of Canada. It was Mr. Bist’s suggestion of the exact proportions of the 2 times length as height as well as the white centre section being 2 times the size of the red borders. He also was responsible for the sizing of the maple leaf to all of the other proportions.  REF, Flag Committee Archives
  • Sept 10th – October 22 1964 Members of the Flag Committee of 1964- All 15 Members of Parliament who worked diligently to bring a recommended National Flag of Canada to Parliament to be voted on in 1964. REF, LAC
  • March 1964 George Stanley – Made the suggestion to John Ross Matheson of a single red maple leaf on a white field be the basis of the National Flag of Canada (recycled Fiset concept) in 1964. REF, Flag Committee Archives
  • 1964 Alan Beddoe – Government of Canada Artist and Heraldry expert who presented Prime Minister Pearson with his own design for a National Flag of Canada which became known as the “Pearson Pennant” and was the beginning point of the “Great Flag Debate” in 1964. REF, Flag Committee Archives
  • October 1964 Arthur Lower – Professor Lower was one of several presenters of information directly to the Flag Committee in October of 1964. His moving statements relating to the opportunity to bring unity to all Canadians through a National Flag was most interesting. REF, Flag Committee Archives
  • October 1964 Conrad Swan – Provided John Ross Matheson with expert advice on the heraldic and historical considerations of a National Flag. REF, Flag Committee Archives
  • October 1964 Fortescue Duguid- Military historian/heraldry expert who presented his input and views of the characteristics and principals of a National Flag for Canada to the Flag Committee in 1964. REF, Flag Committee Archives
  • October 1964 Patrick Reid – The head of the design team at Expositions Canada who was requested to become involved in the final design and creation of the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag as we know it today. REF, LAC
  • Ken Donovan – Working with the team from Expositions Canada, Mr. Donavan was asked to find a company to sew several prototype flags on Friday November 6th, so the Prime Minister could actually fly them over the week-end. Due to the fact it was late on a Friday Mr. Donovan could not find a company to execute this task immediately. He requested his daughter to complete the task because she had a sewing machine and was always ready to help.
  • Joan O’Malley – On Friday November 6th at approximately 8pm Joan O’Malley began working on 3 prototype flags; she sewed until close to midnight to complete all 3. These 3 prototype flags were then delivered to the Prime Minister for his review.  REF, JRM, J O interview
  • November 9th 1964- the final design of the Canadian Maple leaf Flag was produced around 2:30 PM by the team of Jacques Saint Cyr (artist) Patrick Reid (Manager of Design) and John Ross Matheson MP (flag project coordinator) and sent to the Privy Council Office for approval. Alan Winship then made arrangements on Wed. November 10th to send the sketch to Bruck Mills in Cowansville Quebec to have the first prototype of the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag produced. The first prototype was produced on November 16th 1964 and delivered to the Privy Council Office on November 17th.
  • November 1964-June 1966 Dr. Gunter Wyszecki (NRC team)- The involvement on the National Research Council of Canada team began in the wind tunnel testing of the prototype flags in November of 1964. Gunter Wyszecki was also responsible to research the scientific standard of the colours of the National Flag of Canada from February of 1965 to June of 1966.  Dr. Wyszecki and his dedicated team of scientists created the very first scientific standard for colour of a national flag.  There are more than 500,000 shades of red and this team instituted the exact colour of red we, as Canadians admire in the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag flown around the world today.  REF, LAC, NRC Archives
  • December 9th 1964 Lucien Lamoureux – Deputy Speaker of the House of Commons who accepted a motion from the floor of the House of Commons to bring the discussions and debate of the National Flag of Canada to a vote and invoking closure. REF, Hansard Journals
  • December 9th 1964 Leon Balcer – Conservative Member of Parliament from Quebec who requested a motion of closure by the Government on the “Great Flag Debate” REF, Hansard Journals
  • December 9th 1964 Real Caouette – Social Credit Member of Parliament who seconded the motion put forth by Leon Balcer to invoke closure of debate and call a vote on the National Flag of Canada. REF, Hansard Journals
  • 1964-65 Canada’s 26th Parliament – It was one of the most vicious and divisive debates in the history of our Canadian Parliament. The Great Flag Debate raged on for months in the House of Commons.  The final outcome was a 163-78 vote in favour of the National Flag of Canada being accepted as the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag on December 15th  This act of Parliament was beyond doubt, one of the most incredible outcomes from a minority Government in the history of Canada. From this democratic process came the most respected symbol of Canada in the world today.  REF Hansard Journals
  • December 15th 1964 Robert Thompson – Mr. Thompson was Member of the Creditiste Party in Parliament in 1964 and was instrumental in persuading members of his party to vote yes on the flag issue. REF, see vote Hansard Journals
  • December 15th 1964 Paul Martineau – Mr. Martineau was a Conservative MP who worked behind the scenes to convince other Conservative Members of Parliament to vote yes on the flag issue. REF, see vote Hansard Journals
  • December 17th 1964 – Senate of Canada approves the National Flag of Canada as the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag
  • January 28th 1965 Queen Elizabeth II – Proclaimed the National Flag of Canada. This was the final piece of a process which spanned more than 96 years in the making.  REF, LAC
  • February 15th 1965 Archie Cairns – Pipe Major who officially piped the new National Flag of Canada from the Centre Block into Parliament was one of the world’s most respected and accomplished Canadian pipers. REF, LAC
  • February 15th Joseph Secours – 26 year old RCMP officer was chosen to be the person responsible to officially raise the first National Flag of Canada on February 15th 1965. REF, Ottawa Citizen
  • Governor General of Canada Georges Vanier – During the Great Flag Debate and the process to bring the Canadian Maple Leaf Flag to fruition. The Governor-General of Canada is responsible to oversee all of Canada’s symbols and Honours.  REF, LAC

 

The foregoing account and detailed credits are a culmination of my work for the past 6 ½ years and fulfills my promise to John Ross Matheson. I have been humbled as well as proud to have worked this hard to bring this information together so all Canadians have the opportunity to know the names of the many loving hands who worked for nearly 100 years to bring the now most recognized symbol of Canada into being.

This paper is intended to provide historical information, recognition of people and organizations but most of all as the author of this paper I am hoping that each and every person who reads it will have a new found self- awareness of your values as Canadians and a true sense of what it means to make and keep a promise to a friend.

 

Sincerely,

Robert J. (Bob) Harper

Executive Director
Canadian Flag Education Centre

 

 

List of research contacts

2010 – 2017

John Ross Matheson                  “Father of our Flag”

Nevil Johnson                              Lawyer & Business Partner of John Ross Matheson

Alistair Fraser                              Historian/Author Canadian Flag expert

Rick Archbold                              Author/Historian Canadian Flag expert

Auguste Vachon                          Herald Enumerus/Historian/Author

Bruce Patterson                          Deputy Chief Herald of Canada

Joan O’Malley                             Sewed the first prototypes of the 13 point design

John Holtby                                 Parliamentary Library Authority

Queens University Fonds           Holder of John Ross Matheson’s archives

Mount Allison Archives               Holder JRM Thesis from 1975

Madelaine Morrison PHD           Freelance Researcher

Emelie Perrin-Clow PHD            Freelance Researcher

Forrest Pass PHD                      Curator Canadian Museum of History

Michael MacDonald PHD           Manager Library Archives of Canada

Glenn Wright                              Retired researcher from LAC

Paul(Smokie) LeBlanc              Heritage Canada National Flag of Canada

Tanya Fournel                            Government of Canada

Sheila Cimpaye                          Governor-General’s Office

Dick Bourgeois-Doyle                 Secretary-General National Research Council

Roy Mayer                                  National Flag of Canada Day Promoter

Susan Bernard                           Heritage Canada

Robert Watt                                Canada’s first Chief Herald/Honours Chair

Patrick Reid                                Design Team Canadian Maple Leaf Flag

Paul Hellyer                                Member of Parliament 1964 Flag supporter

Paul Hunter                                Toronto Star Journalist

John Geddes                              McClean’s Mag. Journalist/ Jacques St. Cyr story

Rob Reside PHD                        Flag Historian/ Vexilillogist

Ken Reynolds PHD                    DND Historian/Author/ Vexilollogist

Hansard Journals                       26th Parliament of Canada records

John Mackie                               Freelance Journalist/ Patrick Reid story

Ted Kaye                                    International renowned Vexilollogist

Paul Martin Jr.                            Prime Minister and friend of JRM

Peter Warren                             Canada’s most accomplished investigative journalist

Larry Rosenthal                         Bruck Mills Historian

Allan Winship                             Lawyer, Privy Council Office 1964

Privy Council Office                   Archival Section

Anthony Wilson-Smith               President/CEO Historica Canada

Historica Canada                      Joanne Archibald administration

Canadian Encyclopedia            Web content group

Ian Kyer                                     Lawyer, wrote Biography of Edward M Chadwick

Fionna Cairns                            Daughter of Major Archie Cairns

Matheson Family                       Detailed stories of JRM

Candice Bist                              Daughter of George Bist credited with sizing details